In the Saturday Op-eds, The Washington Post again called out the Bush administration for falsely claiming that tax cuts pay for themselves. Tax cuts pay for themselves in much the same way that a ten cent coupon pays for a can of soup. Yes, some tax cuts help stimulate the economy, but no study has found that tax cuts are self-funding.

Estimates range, but a sample of three non-partisan studies indicates that income tax cuts do not pay for themselves - not even close. Most studies indicate that tax cuts do increase personal income and consumption, resulting in a very moderate economic stimulus. But this minor boost in economic growth does not replenish government coffers. For every $100 lost to tax cuts, the government only recoups between 10% to 28% due to economic growth. Even former chairman of President Bush’s Council of Economic Advisors, Gregory Mankiw’s most rosy estimates demonstrate that tax cuts lose 50% of their value.

So tax cuts cost the government money. End of story. Unless you’re the president writing an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal:

It is also a fact that our tax cuts have fueled robust economic growth and record revenues. … The bottom line is tax relief and spending restraint are good for the American worker, good for the American taxpayer, and good for the federal budget. Now is not the time to raise taxes on the American people.

Tax relief has benefited the American worker - as long as you’re talking about the American worker in a household making more than $100,000 per year. According to a study by the non-partisan Tax Policy Center, last year’s tax “relief” amounted a whopping $68 to the 125 million households making less than $100,000. Meanwhile the 20 million earning more than $100,000 received an average of $2,861 per household, 42 times more tax relief than those at the bottom of the income scale.

Indeed, now is the time for Democrats to end Bush’s tax cuts for the rich.

And if you have to pour over tax policies in great depth, I would recommend Tim Hecker’s album Harmonies in Ultraviolet (number 14 on Pitchfork’s best of 2006): ambient static and dissonance for blogging in the middle of a rainy night.

*Mankiw: Income Tax Cut measured with dynamic scoring

Sources: Washington Post, Congressional Budget Office, Wikipedia, Tax Policy Center

Post a Comment | Trackback URI